What Is Transmitted Between Two Existences? Reincarnation and the Work of Dr. Ian Stevenson

By Philippe Judenne

A white corridor of arches leading into the distance

What is transmitted to a being that takes birth? For the sciences, the individual is the fruit of his or her genetic heritage and family experience, or purely the product of interactions with the environment. Where the sciences debate the part between the innate and the acquired from the zero point of conception or birth of a living being, Buddhist spirituality considers that only the law of causality of karma is at work and makes successive rebirths manifest: it recognizes an innate character to each newborn, fruit of a previous karma, and an acquired character which is built as new actions, new karmic acts at the level of the body, the word and the spirit of an individual advancing in the life. It does not consider that there is a zero point of the beginning of the existence of a current of consciousness, which is remanifested differently in successive existences and in different spheres of existence. At the moment of death, the stream of consciousness, which was created by the separation from the body, no longer has the limits of the physical body, and it is the “wind of karma” that will determine its rebirth. How then does karmic energy manifest itself from one existence to another? Or, if we rephrase the question more simply out of a Buddhist frame of reference, how would be defined what is transmitted to a human being who takes birth?

Dr. Ian Stevenson was Professor of Psychiatry and Director of DOPS from 1967 to 2002 at the University of Virginia, USA. Over the years, he studied and corroborated thousands of children’s accounts of memories of an existence chronologically prior to their birth. These young children demonstrated memories, skills, behaviors and knowledge that could not be expected of a child their age in their usual environment. Questions arose first in the family, which could then sometimes take them outside the family circle.

Traumatic memories

Ian Stevenson and his teams studied and investigated in Asia, the Middle East and America, and in 1979, they succeeded in listing nearly 600 cases “suggesting reincarnation”. Stevenson’s work challenged established scientific theories, such as genetic or behavioral determinism. Thus, he cautiously called his most convincing cases “cases suggesting reincarnation”, which emerged from rigorous investigations carried out in the field.

Some of the memories were traumatic and perhaps linked to phobias observed in young children whose bodies could have scars or marks of unknown origin. It was with a view to treating these childhood phobias that Ian Stevenson first became interested in the children’s stories and their astonishing accuracy. “One of the cases was that of a little girl in Sri Lanka who showed both a great aversion to water and an intense fright at the sight of buses. As soon as she could speak, she told of how, in another situation, she had backed away hastily from a passing bus, fallen into a flooded field, and drowned.”

A death that is not very peaceful, like the one told by children who are phobic about a type of weapon, the very one that their stories, their memories designate each time as the weapon of the murder experienced at that moment. For it is indeed a question of memories, but not those of the children. Jim B. Tucker, who took up the work of Ian Stevenson in 2002 and who is very involved in the DOPS at the University of Virginia, reports that “in about 70% of the cases of American children who claim to remember past lives, the deceased died of an unnatural cause, which suggests that traumatic death may be linked to the supposed survival of a self”. The strength of the memory, of the reminiscence, seems to be very much linked to that of the emotion experienced at the moment of death in violent cases, which in no way presumes the survival of a “self”, refuted by the Buddhist tradition.

An old twin-lens reflex camera

An exceptional wealth of memories

Other cases of exceptional richness of memories have been verified and corroborated by the university researcher. In his interview with Ian Stevenson in 1979, Joël André reports that an exceptional case, the most fascinating of them all according to Dr Stevenson, was that of a little Lebanese boy, Imad Elawar. Born in 1958, Imad claimed at the age of three to have lived in another village and described in great detail the places and people he had known there. He recounted various significant episodes of this previous life (accidents, fights, hunting, etc.), spoke of “his” house and the places in it where various objects were located, and nostalgically evoked his friends and the beautiful young woman with whom he had lived. Out of sixty indications provided by Imad, fifty-seven proved to be strictly accurate. The great strength of this case, explains Joël André, is that Prof. Stevenson knew about it before the meeting between Imad’s family and the family of the deceased, that the latter claimed to be a certain Ibrahim Bouhamy, who died of tuberculosis in 1949. Professor Stevenson was thus able to list all of Imad’s claims before taking him to the village mentioned by the child, for a verification that was thus carried out from beginning to end by Stevenson himself.

Remarkable emotional attitudes

Joël André asked Ian Stevenson this question: “At this stage of a case, what are the most convincing facts? And, more generally, on what do you base your personal intuition of the authenticity of a case?

Ian Stevenson: “I could, of course, cite the extraordinary abundance of subsequently verified information, but that in itself does not justify the reincarnation hypothesis alone. On the other hand, certain emotional attitudes seem to me to be remarkable, especially in countries like India where the smallest family and neighborhood relationships are closely codified. That the child recognizes correctly the persons who are presented to him, that he gives their exact names, is a first thing. But when he avoids the false recognitions offered to him, when he behaves towards each member of his previous family in perfect accord with the attitude of son, husband or wife that he is supposed to have been in that family, the likelihood of reincarnation increases. A five-year-old child, Sukla, was thus able to behave towards the one she recognized as her daughter Minu, who had grown up in the meantime, with an emotional spontaneity and maternal authority that were quite remarkable. She could address men thirty or forty years older than her as if she were still the housewife she claimed to have been. And, an important detail for those who know the psychology of Indian homes, she ate from the same plate as “her” husband of a previous life, something no Indian woman would do in relation to another family member or a stranger.”

According to Stevenson, it is difficult to say that one is dealing with a single personality in the child. Rather, he spoke of a continuity or juxtaposition of two personalities. At a certain moment, the child assumes an adult position, linked to a previous life. If he remembers being a banker, for example, he talks about “his” money, “his” accounts, “his” business, etc. The next moment he is playing a game with his friends. The next moment he is playing like any other child of his age. But he can “go back to being a banker” at any time, especially when an element of the present context reminds him of the one in which he says he lived. There are therefore coexisting personalities, but the one from the previous life is as consistent as the current one.

Unlearned abilities

Professor Stevenson relates the case of a Brazilian child, Paulo, who claimed to be the reincarnation of Emilia, a young girl who had died 16 months earlier. Emilia had shown a real genius for sewing and embroidery. The young Paulo seemed to perpetuate the essence of it. His older sister remembers that Paulo had a gift for sewing from an early age. One day when a maid was clumsily trying to use a sewing machine, Paulo pushed her aside and showed her how it should be done. He was four years old when another of his sisters had trouble with the sewing machine’s spool. Again, Paulo solved the problem.

Another sister had left an embroidery on the machine to be finished: in her absence, Paulo finished the work without any help. The whole family agreed that the child knew how to use the machine “before he learned”. When asked to explain this amazing ability, he replied, “I knew how to sew before.” When they wanted to encourage him by offering him sewing lessons, he replied, “I already know.”

Even more technical seems to be the performance of an Indian child, Parmod, who claimed the personality of a deceased merchant named Paramand. Parmod cited a host of accurate details about the deceased’s life and spoke with ease about Paramand’s possessions (store, cinema, hotel) as if he had managed them himself. On his first visit to “his old store”, he immediately asked, “Who’s running the bakery and the soda factory?” (These were the two main activities of the late Paramand.) Brought in front of the soda machine, Parmod explained exactly how it worked. He was then asked to start it up. The water supply had been cut off without his knowledge to embarrass him. Parmod understood, however, without any help, how this machine (very complicated according to Prof. Stevenson) had to be started again.

Old letters and photographs tied with string

Transmigration

For years, Ian Stevenson has carefully controlled his accounts and exposed his methods of investigation. The very serious Journal of the American Medical Association or JAMA, an international peer-reviewed medical journal, concluded as early as 1975: “On the subject of reincarnation, Stevenson has carefully and unbiasedly compiled a series of detailed cases. The facts reported can hardly be explained by any other hypothesis than that of reincarnation.”

In forty years, the avenues opened up by Ian Stevenson have made it possible to broaden the current paradigm by founding the hypothesis that consciousness is something greater than a physically produced phenomenon, a hypothesis that is more precise and effective than the dominant materialist view. Memories, emotional attitudes and abilities can be remanifested from one existence to another, Stevenson’s work documents and largely answers this question. Stevenson’s follow-up of children shows that as they age, children’s “before” memories fade into memories of memories, compared to the much more vivid and current memories of their present lives.

Scattered old photographs

The Division of Perceptual Studies

Founded in 1967 by Dr. Ian Stevenson, the Division of Perceptual Studies (DOPS) is the world’s oldest and most productive academic research group devoted exclusively to the study of phenomena that challenge the current physical orthodoxy regarding the brain and mind, including phenomena directly suggesting the postmortem survival of consciousness.

Through its research, DOPS rigorously evaluates the empirical evidence suggesting that consciousness survives death and that the mind and brain are distinct and separable.


About the author

Philippe Judenne is editor-in-chief of the magazine Sagesses Bouddhistes published by the French Buddhist Federation. Trained as an engineer and father of three, he has been managing media projects for over 10 years. He has been practising Vajrayana in the Karma Kagyu tradition for about twenty years.

This article first appeared in EBU Magazine #7 – Death and Dying from a Buddhist Perspective (Autumn 2021). Download the full issue as PDF or browse all issues.

Retour en haut