When a Blossom Falls: A Course in Meditation for Parents Who Have Lost a Child

By Dario Doshin Girolami

Blossoming cherry trees reflected in water

Some time ago, I was asked by the Maruzzo Lefebvre D’Ovidio Foundation for palliative care to lead a course in meditation that would help people in processing grief. A group of twelve people – six sets of parents who had lost a child – were already attending group psychotherapy at the Foundation. At a certain point, their therapist, – who had personal experience of meditation – realized that meditation practice might help these parents overcome their suffering.

The pain that follows a loss is a natural emotion. And the normal reaction to this pain can manifest itself at physical, emotional, cognitive, and behavioral levels. However, if it is treated in an effective way, pain itself can generate powerful insights, and lead to a deeper emotional and existential maturity. The traditional Buddhist practice of meditating with awareness has been shown to be a remarkable tool for processing grief, especially when combined with effective psychotherapy.

The application of this meditation technique in resolving the pain that accompanies grief, in particular when it is occasioned by the death of a child, originates directly from the wisdom of the historical Buddha. There is in fact in the Buddhist Canon the story of a woman who has lost her own child. In her desperation, she wanders the streets, carrying in her arms the lifeless body of her son, pleading for medicine that could bring him back to life. Buddha noticed the woman and told her he knew of a medicine, but first the woman must gather a handful of mustard seeds, taking each seed from a family that had never suffered grief. The woman went house to house, but it did not take her long to understand the reality of death, and to accept, in particular, the death of her own son.

Buddha also taught that the contemplation of death is the most noble of all contemplations. It is like the footprint of an elephant: the footprints of all other animals fit inside it. So, all other contemplations are subsets of the contemplation of death.

The First Noble Truth, as Buddha defined it, is that life is suffering. The Second Noble Truth is that the origin of suffering is attachment. More specifically, Buddha teaches that reality is impermanent. Everything changes constantly: what is born, dies. Nothing is forever. When we become attached to things or people and delude ourselves that they will last forever, when those things or people die, or the relationships end, that is when suffering arises.

The practice of meditation on the breath trains us in the observation of impermanence. Breath—like the present moment—is here for an instant and then passes. Bringing attention to the breath makes it possible for us to realize that breath is life and death at every instant. It is not a coincidence that Zen Buddhism teaches that we die at each breath.

But Buddhism also sees death as a normal process, a natural part of life. In Zen, death is considered a teaching that reveals the truth of impermanence, of compassion, of interdependence.

Paralleling the five stages of grief described by Elizabeth Kübler-Ross (denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance), the Buddhist Zen tradition has developed teachings in which interior tranquility helps one to accept rather than deny; the practice of patience helps to calm anger and negativity; the development of a wider perspective, through mindfulness, helps to alleviate depression and pain; the practice of nonattachment helps in the process of deep acceptance and metabolization of grief.

Compassion, patience, and being sensitive to the human condition can help remove what is blocking us and help us be more tolerant of our aversion to suffering. This can lead to a profound acceptance of what happens.

When we open ourselves to the immensity, the mystery of life, whatever has been causing us anguish dissolves, and we can enter the powerful dimension of the unknown.

Once, a student asked Katagiri Roshi—Japanese Zen master, third abbot of the San Francisco Zen Center: “What is the difference between life and death?” He replied, “There is none! They are the same thing. They are two sides of the same coin. It is we who separate them. But life and death are two aspects of the same reality.”

Lavoisier’s law, according to which nothing is created and nothing is destroyed, is easy for us westerners to understand. Can we manage to see life and death from the same perspective?

In the Zen tradition, we recite the Heart of Perfect Wisdom Sutra, the central teaching of which is that emptiness is form and form is emptiness; emptiness does not differ from form, and form does not differ from emptiness. To understand this profound teaching, we may take the example of the wave and water. Water has no form but may take the form of a wave. But the wave and the water are not separable. Without water, there is no wave. They are one and the same, that is, two sides of the same coin. The reality in which we live is form, but—from the Zen perspective—it is the manifestation of that which has no form, that is, of the Absolute. “Absolute” in the sense of “free from,” not understandable, not thinkable, unless it takes a form.

Let us try now to substitute the terms “form and emptiness” for the terms “life and death.” What is the difference between form and emptiness? What is the difference between life and death? Form is not different from emptiness, emptiness is not different from form. Life is not different from death. Death is not different from life.

A person meditating on a rock above a sea of clouds

Once a week, for many months, the twelve course participants were given these teachings, after forty minutes of group meditation. In the very lively discussions that always followed meditation and the Dharma talk, the parents were able to express, without fear, their deep suffering.

A theme that they often came back to was injustice: “It was unjust, it was a mistake, that my son died when he was only eight years old,” they said to me, in tears. With huge respect for their pain, very gently, I explained to them that in our western culture we tend not to think about death. When we do have to confront it, we delude ourselves that the moment of death should arrive when someone is around eighty or ninety years old. So if death arrives before then, we consider it a misfortune or an injustice. But if we observe reality mindfully – as meditation teaches us to do – we realize that death happens when it happens, and not when we expect it, and we realize that there is nothing wrong with this. If we observe nature we can see that not all the buds on a plant become flowers or fruit. Many buds fall. But their fall causes no harm. The trajectory of their fall is easy and perfect. Zen teaches that this is “the Way of things.”

In the same manner, when the leaves fall in autumn, they don’t all fall together on 22 September, on the morning of the equinox. On the contrary, some fall earlier and some, later. Nothing bad happened to those that fell earlier. It is simply the Way of things, the way that things function in this impermanent reality.

Little by little, this teaching became absorbed into the hearts of the parents like a healing balm. Meditation by meditation, they widened their perspective, including thus in their idea of life the death that manifests itself at all times. The image of the bud that falls spoke profoundly to their psyche and liberated them from the oppressive feeling of injustice, which had done nothing more than add pain to the already terrible pain of their loss.

A young woman blowing dandelion seeds

But beside this there was also a sense of blame: “I didn’t do enough,” they told me, sobbing, “I should have protected or cured my child.”

Once more, the practice of meditation came to their aid. If we look deeply, we may notice that it is the ego that produces phrases of this kind, in a kind of delirium of omnipotence. What can we do, in fact, when faced with an incurable illness? What can we do when faced with a natural disaster? Clearly, it is not within our power to change such things, but what we can most surely do is develop compassion for ourselves, for our children, and for all sentient beings immersed in a world that we cannot control. Compassion is the cure. It may not cure the body, but it can certainly cure the heart. A sense of guilt, meanwhile, cures nothing; rather, it makes the pain more obdurate, more difficult to cure.

This teaching, too, gradually created an opening, and forgiveness and compassion took the place of guilt in the hearts of the suffering parents.

Finally, a powerful fear emerged: “If I open my heart to the Way of things, if I let go of my guilt, haven’t I then forgotten my child?” they asked me, almost terrified.

People who begin meditation often do not understand well the teaching of abiding in the present moment and make the mistake of believing that this means forgetting the past. But the problem here is not our memories. Memory is an extraordinary function and absolutely necessary for living. The problem, rather, lies in our being invaded against our own will by memories and projections that drag us away from the present moment. When that happens, we are like lost and melancholy ghosts, wandering about in a misty past.

The present moment is the only real dimension. The past is past. The future is still to be. The only dimension that really exists is the present moment.

When they realized this, the parents found their minds were clearer: they had opened themselves to the reality of the present moment without thereby forgetting their children who were no longer present.

Listening deeply to these teachings, carrying them over into their own lives, the parents little by little, over the course of a year, opened themselves to life.

Some even decided to have another child – a clear sign that they had overcome their trauma – while others simply began to smile again and to see their child in every bud.

Golden Buddha statues

About the author

Dario Doshin Girolami, M.Phil., is a Soto-Zen priest and a Dharma Teacher in the lineage of Shunryu Suzuki Roshi. Former Adjunct Professor of Zen at John Cabot University and of Comparative Religion at the American University of Rome, he currently teaches Buddhism and holds regular seminars at the Faculty of Psychology at Sapienza University of Rome, and teaches Meditation at Rebibbia Prison – Rome.

This article first appeared in EBU Magazine #7 – Death and Dying from a Buddhist Perspective (Autumn 2021). Download the full issue as PDF or browse all issues.

Прокрутить вверх