Cooperation and Reverence

By Dharmavidya David Brazier – Keynote at the EBU conference “Buddhism in Europe: Unity in Diversity”, Nantes, April 2022

Silhouette of an island with trees at sunset, reflected in calm water

It’s very nice to be here with all of you. I must say I feel a little overawed at being at an in person conference after such a long time of isolation enforced by the pandemic. It’s very good to be here. I’m the first speaker so I thought I might use my presentation to raise some questions and share some things that we might then go on talking about in the time ahead. So probably more questions than answers here.

I think I was originally asked to give this presentation because at a previous meeting I had referred to my book called “The Dark Side of the Mirror” which is about the text Genjo Koan by Dogen Zen. So the book is a book about a Zen Master written by myself a “Pure Land” Buddhist teacher. The book was published by Windhorse which is the publishing arm of the Triratna Sangha. So the book, which I have got here, is itself a tangible example of co-operation between Buddhist traditions, and substantially that’s what EBU is all about so Ron kindly asked me if I would give this talk since I have produced this item which makes co-operation between Buddhist Sanghas a reality. It raises the whole question of how much such co-operation is possible and how much it’s desirable and I can see several angles to this question. I haven’t got time to deal with them all but I can see that all our traditions they all spring from a single root, and the teachings of Sakyamuni are there. Perhaps we interpret them differently, perhaps we practise differently but these are all ways that we can show to one another to help one another. When I travel around the Buddhist world when I am in the West all too often as soon as I appear people want to know –What is your tradition? What is your practice? In a way that is kind of exclusive – Are you one of us or are you another group? Whereas when I am in the East again people want to know about practice and so on but it has a very different feel. You arrive at a temple. Perhaps the priest takes you in front of the altar and immediately we do some practice. We do some practice in whatever his style is, we ring bells and chant Sutras and so on. Perhaps we circumambulate the altar or perhaps we don’t but we do some practice, and then afterwards probably they serve tea and we sit down and the priest says “and what do you do?” It’s said with a kind of genuine interest, curiosity, alacrity. Our practice our way of celebrating the Buddha, celebrating the Dharma, celebrating the Sangha. These are things we can share with one another, things that we like to receive from one another. They are not tokens of membership of exclusive groups. They are things that connect us. So I really have a very strong hope that in the West, in Europe especially, we can make this diversity that we have into an asset rather than a liability. We have a very difficult history behind us as Europeans. So much time and energy has been wasted on conflicts between religious groups on this continent. I certainly hope that we don’t become trapped in that kind of conflictual sectarianism. That we are able to demonstrate something different. Something that is a manifestation of the spirit of the Dharma, the spirit of harmony, of co-operation, of working together.

So that’s my first point really.

In contrast to this I would like to share, a little, about what’s happened in my own Sangha over the past few years. I was the head of the Amida order for approaching twenty years and during that time many people developed in their Dharma practice, advanced along the spiritual path, and some of them became teachers and gradually I would hand over responsibility to other people and all this went extremely well and people took on responsibilities and so on. Little by little I would step back and pass over the reins to other people. And then along came the pandemic and somebody suggested to me that I might start making podcasts. So I did that and out of this a group of new people came into the Sangha and they started to meet and soon we were having online meetings.

Everybody was going on to zoom and we were no different. So a whole range of zoom meetings started to happen and mostly these were the new people and I was much involved in facilitating these groups, and the people from the existing Sangha, you might say the old Sangha, (some of whom were kind of itching to get more responsibility and to do things in their own way), didn’t want to come to these meetings and, to cut a long story short, what has actually happened is that the Sangha that we had three years ago has now split into maybe half a dozen separate groups. The different teachers have taken different directions. This, of course, is something that we have seen over and over again in Buddhist history. Most of the important teachers that we read about had several leading disciples and in due course those disciples go off and do their own thing in their own way with their own people. So when we look at the history of Buddhism what we see is a sort of branching tree structure. From every bough there come branches, from every branch there come twigs, it spreads out like this. So we have these two different tendencies in Buddhism. On the one hand there is nothing intrinsic in the Dharma that prevents groups from co-operating and getting together. At the same time there is a natural tendency towards bifurcation, towards diversification, towards splitting -as we move from generation to generation, as the Sangha grows and the transmission of the Dharma is through a multiplicity of people. Sometimes they say there are as many Dharmas as Lamas. Each teacher has their own style, they develop their own group in their own way. So two contrasting tendencies, a kind of dialectic probably between the two and so there is a sort of challenge for us to see. Can we make this into a richness which will be fertile ground for the Dharma in the future or is it going to be, like so many times in the past on this continent, a scene of conflict and strife. I guess it is up to us but it is certainly something to think about. I remember that the Dalai Lama was once asked if it would be a good thing if all the different schools of Buddhism were unified. And I remember him saying: “Oh no very bad idea, there is a great diversity of people. Diverse groups of people call for diverse presentations of the Dharma”. So we need this diversity, many groups, many styles, many front doors through which people can come into the house of the Dharma. But once they come through that door we hope that what they will find is love, harmony, compassion, wisdom and not conflict, strife, exclusivism. This is the challenge that we face.

Illustration for the article “Cooperation and Reverence” (EBU Magazine #9)

Ok that’s that I wanted to say those things, I feel they are quite important. Many people these days are inclined to see religion, and they will count Buddhism as a religion, as being simply a source of trouble and conflict. We have this wound in our culture from the religious conflicts and persecutions that there have been in the past. If we could present a religion which can manifest genuine friendship, co-operation and so on, this could have a hugely healing effect upon our whole continent. It would affect people, not just Buddhist people but everybody. I am now starting to reflect on what you might call the spirit of our times, the culture that we live in. And there is something that I want to say about this because I suspect that we maybe at the cusp of a quite substantial change in the spirit of our times – the culture that we are living in, the assumptions that we make, things that seem most fundamental, things that we just take for granted. What I have in mind here is that if we think back over history, for several hundred years there has been emerging a kind of what is sometimes called “modernism”, a rather rational view of society which has given rise to capitalism and to big technological advances of one sort or another, materialism in various forms.

At the bottom of this collection of broad trends it seems to me that there has been a deep belief in progress. There has been the idea, the assumption, that things inevitably, overall, get better. Even if we are knocked back a bit by wars or disasters of one sort or another, still people have had a faith that their grand children will inevitably occupy a better world that we do ourselves now. This belief has been there, this belief in a sort of inevitability of progress has been deeply ingrained in our culture, in all the assumptions we make, for certainly 200 years, probably rather longer, perhaps since the renaissance. Now when we do think in a kind of historical and comparative fashion this actually is rather unusual. Most of the great civilisations in history have not had this kind of belief in such a central and fundamental place, if they had it at all. Many of the greatest civilisations felt that the golden age was way back in the past. Certainly this was true in China, it was probably true in Ancient Greece. Many of the great civilisations have had this kind of assumption that what was inevitable was that we were in decline, things were getting worse. People believed that life expectancy was getting less not getting more, that things were getting more difficult. Actually we see this notion, this fundamental notion of decline in Buddhism. In many schools of Buddhism, actually throughout the Buddhist world there are notions of the decline, the stages in the decline of the Dharma. If you were alive at the time of the Buddha then you got the perfect Dharma, the real thing in its fullness. Then five hundred years later, well you certainly had access to some good teachers, but you didn’t get Sakyamuni himself. A thousand years later things were even more difficult, and then grew up the notion of Mappo, of the Dharma ending age. And this notion of decline was certainly part of the taken for granted assumption that was in the background of the culture when Buddhist schools were taking shape; new schools in South Asia, East Asia, China, Japan. They were formed in a climate of public opinion in which the basic assumption was decline. We, in the West, have had this staunch belief in the opposite, in progress. Things get better. We are willing to invest because we think in the future there will be more like that. This is deeply ingrained in all our assumptions, or at least it has been until pretty recently. There are some signs that things are changing. If you do a survey of people now and say “Do you think your grand children will live in a better world than you do?” many people are nowadays, inclined to say no. And this is a very recent phenomenon. I would say, if you had to date it at all, it maybe began with the financial crash, the subprime loans debacle. It’s been accentuated by the experience of the pandemic, but fundamentally it’s due to our growing awareness of the ecological peril that we are in. It’s very hard to be optimistic, to believe that humans are going to do what is necessary to prevent ecological disaster. We have these big conferences, international agreements, the Paris accords, and so on. They never seem to be enough, they don’t go anywhere near it. I read that during the first really severe lockdown at the beginning of the Pandemic there was a sharp reduction in economic activity, in the use of fossil fuels and so on. They said you could see the Himalayas from Katmandu instead of seeing smog like you usually do. But even that apparently, was not as much as we would actually need to change in order to prevent global warming getting out of hand. At that time some people said we have an opportunity to do it now, but of course we didn’t we all wanted to get back to normal. Normal is what is destroying the planet and as we gradually become more and more aware of this a certain sense of Mappo, of the Kaliuga of the Dharma ending age is bound to arise in us.

Is this going to mean that we change the way that we present the Dharma. Is there something that the Dharma can say in this time of crisis when the whole human species is facing an unprecedented threat?

I think I’m going to have to leave it with you but I do think it is a very important question and it may well mean that the way that we view the Dharma itself changes. We have to a substantial degree in the West remade the Dharma that we imported from Asia, we have reshaped it to fit our Western attitudes and our Western assumptions. As I have already said those assumptions were not the ones that prevailed at the time when the schools of Dharma that we practice came into being. Is that going to change now? Are we going to see some of the more traditional ways in a new light. I don’t know but it’s a very interesting question.

OK so I have raised some questions. I hope I have made us think a little bit.

I’d like to share with you a little bit about one particular project which I’m involved in and in some ways has come about in relation to some of these problems. This project is called “Oasis de Longue Vie”. It’s in central France. It’s a small community conceived as being for ageing Buddhists, Buddhist in their later years from any Buddhist school. It was the brainchild of Lama Sherab Namdreul and when it started it was a very small idealistic project. It started with three people. They searched around and they bought some land with a building on it and I think they put a caravan on the land and that is how it started, and they started building. Soon the caravan wasn’t needed any more because they had built two new houses. So the three people they have now got three houses. After three years or so there were still only three people and then one of those died. At this point it looked like the whole project might fold up but they persevered and pretty soon more people started to come along. There are now seven actual residents, several new houses have been built. There will soon be nine residents. There are more people coming and they are well connected with their local community so that when they have their festival days maybe sixty people show up. There is a meditation hall, there is a Stupa, there is also a swimming pool. Each of the residents has their own self contained house. It is not a communal community in the sense of shared meals or shared washing or anything like that. Each person has an independent house. This means that the co-operation that happens between people is entirely voluntary. Events get organised, practice sessions are set up and so on, but you don’t have to go if you don’t want to. You can just stay in your house.

Illustration for the article “Cooperation and Reverence” (EBU Magazine #9)

In actual fact, a huge amount of co-operation occurs and some of the residents are a lot more able bodied than others; they help one another. It’s a very successful project now and it provides a wonderful alternative to institutional care or the loneliness of old age. It also fits in with the notion of co-operation and of creating communities or settlements, small settlements, in the countryside away from the big cities, which may well be what will be needed if ecological problems persist. One of the principles here is small is beautiful, so they don’t really want their project to grow and grow and grow. Many of the excellencies of the project, the harmony and co-operation and so on, would be much more difficult to sustain in a larger group of people. So probably there will be a limit, ten or a dozen people living there. However there is a pretty steady trickle of visitors who come and say this is wonderful. I would really like to be part of this. Maybe now, maybe later in my life, but it’s attractive. So, I was thinking about this and I live about 15 kilometers away from Oasis. I live in a Hermitage with some land. Having thought about it, I propose that my land could become a basis for Oasis Two, a second Oasis, if there is a demand, if there is a need. I would be willing to give my own land and buildings if other people will come forward with the capital to do the building, because we would need to build houses. It would be, like Oasis one, a self governing community, each resident having one vote in the association which would own the land and buildings, which would be a kind of cross between a housing association and a religious charity. We have a blue print, we know how it is done because Oasis One have jumped through all the hoops already. Will it happen? Well we will have to wait and see. But for me it’s one way of putting into practice the kind of co-operation, inter Sangha harmony, that I’ve been talking about in this talk. It may also be a way of responding to the changing atmosphere of our times. You may have noticed that up until the pandemic, certainly in France, there was a strong tendency for the countryside to become increasingly empty as people moved into the cities. Since the pandemic this has gone into reverse. People are moving out of the cities into the countryside. But they don’t want to be in the countryside in total isolation. So perhaps we are an idea whose time has come. Well we will see.

It’s just an example. It would be nice to see it as part of the spirit of the European Buddhist Union.

Pure Land tradition has a somewhat distinctive take on the Dharma and how it should be practised. It is very much a Dharma for ordinary people. It is not really so much a Dharma for ascetic monks living in monasteries. It’s a Dharma for ordinary citizens living busy lives out in society. Therefore it involves a recognition of the strengths but more particularly the limitations of that situation. The founders of Pure Land in Japan certainly took the view that we don’t have in this present age (perhaps Mappo), we do not have it in us to become enlightened by our own effort. It simply isn’t practical. It is not feasible to lift oneself up by one’s bootstraps into being a Buddha when one is an ordinary person in this world. It can’t be done. But what is possible is to have a relationship with Buddha. To be grateful for what Buddha has given us, which has been given like a grace.

Illustration for the article “Cooperation and Reverence” (EBU Magazine #9)

When Buddha died some people would say he was a pioneer. We have to follow in his footsteps and achieve what he achieved. But you know, Buddha was a pretty exceptional case. Other people would say, no it wasn’t quite like that. I was in my village. I hadn’t done a great amount of spiritual practice. Maybe none at all and the Buddha came into our village. I had a twenty minute conversation with him and my life has never been the same since. That change was not brought about by my effort, it was not brought about by my practice, my training, my ethical discipline, my study of the Sutras, or anything of the kind. It was brought about by a power outside of myself. It was brought about by the Buddha coming into my life and I have never been as I was before since that time. I’ve been transformed by other power and I am immensely grateful. So my practice is not really to achieve something, I don’t want to be him but I do want to express my profound gratitude for what he has done for me, what he has given me, for the Dharma which has come into my life as such a grace. This is kind of the tone of Pure Land and I personally have found it amazingly liberating. It takes away all the anxiety of how am I doing with my practice. And it gives me a framework within which it is much easier to acknowledge my own shortcomings, vulnerability, limitations, emotions, my proneness to making mistakes forgetting things, getting things wrong. In Japanese we call this Bombu, our Bombu nature, and when you can face that shadow side of yourself and see it’s reality it gives rise to a certain kind of humility. It gives rise to compassion, because you see that this must be the case for everybody else as well and it gives rise to the sense of the huge gap or distance between how I am and how Buddha is. And this is a basis for devotion, adoration. So these are the characteristics of the Pure Land school. It is a relatively, you might say, religious form of Buddhism in which we worship, adore the Buddha and call his name. We are constantly calling the Buddha’s name, which means we are constantly taking refuge. Taking refuge is at the heart of every school of Buddhism and we make that our practice.

So we are about at the end of our time. If we have that kind of gratitude to the Buddhas we want to put their spirit into practice and I hope we can do it in the cooperative and harmonious ways I have talked about. I hope we can be sensitive to the ambient society around us and the way it’s changing and the problems. I hope we can find responses to those changes. I hope the things I have said interest you. If there is anyone out there who’s interested in the oasis project come and talk to me. If anyone wants to know more about Pure Land Buddhism talk to me, but from now on I shall be listening to all the other great teachers who are going to come and speak to us at this conference.

Illustration for the article “Cooperation and Reverence” (EBU Magazine #9)

Thank you very much.


About the author

Dharmavidya David Brazier (Rev. Dr.) is head of the Amida Order and Amida Shu Pureland sangha. He is the author of more than a dozen books and many other writings. He is an authority on Buddhist psychology and President of the International Zen Therapy Institute.

This article first appeared in EBU Magazine #9 – EBU Conference 2022 – Buddhism in Europe: Unity in Diversity (Autumn 2022). Download the full issue as PDF or browse all issues.

Прокрутить вверх