Buddhism in Europe, Unity in Diversity: A Challenge, a Model and Hope for Peace in Europe

By Claudine Carayol – Talk at the EBU conference “Buddhism in Europe: Unity in Diversity”, Nantes, April 2022

Black-and-white close-up of two hands of different skin colours clasped together

I will first present diversity, the fundamental characteristic of all existence, according to the Buddha’s Teachings, then the diversity of European nations and finally the diversity of Buddhist traditions in Europe. You will then understand why I used the word “challenge” which contains the idea of taking on an ambitious and difficult project, such as unity.

I will then talk about the path that leads to unity in diversity, a path that makes diversity an asset and not a source of conflicts. I will conclude by talking about the EBU (European Buddhist Union) as a federation that can contribute to harmony and peace in Europe.

What does the Buddha teach about the diversity of human beings?

As mentioned in my introduction, according to the Buddha’s Teachings, diversity is one of the fundamental characteristics of the reality of all existence, and therefore of human beings. Each person has his or her own place and plays his or her own part, within impermanence and interdependence, according to his or her own nature. Each existence is unique, particular. In perpetual transformation, it is subject to innumerable conditionings – positive or negative – linked to past actions and their effects. For the effects of actions do not disappear but will always manifest themselves, in a near or distant future, under certain conditions. Human beings, however, are by nature ignorant of these principles which govern reality. They are unable to know the deep causes of the circumstances they encounter and under which conditions these circumstances appear. They are also ignorant of the truth of their conditioned nature and of the truth of their essential nature.

Human beings, who are so diverse, are capable of producing sublime masterpieces, showing the utmost self-sacrifice and exemplary courage. The Buddha teaches that human beings, endowed with marvellous qualities and great talents, are also endowed with the potential to achieve the state of Enlightenment that he himself attained. Yet, let us not forget he also teaches that human beings belong to the ten states of existence – worlds to which all sentient beings belong, in varying proportions – and as such, they also belong to the lower worlds.

These worlds are made up of the lower states – those of demons, of spirits with insatiable desires, of animals and quarrelsome spirits -, then the world of human beings, the world of celestial spirits, and the world of practitioners of the Buddha’s Teachings (traditionally divided into three groups, shravakas, pratyekabuddhas and bodhisattvas but we will come back to this division later). The world of the Enlightened, the Buddhas, represents the ultimate state, that of supreme Enlightenment.

This clarification of the complexity and diversity of human nature seems important to me. We belong to these different worlds, we and our family members, those who have preceded us on this earth and whose heritage we have received, as well as all the beings we encounter in this life.

This awareness -and the humility that stems from it- are precious, just as the other great principles enunciated by the Buddha, for they are essential to the building of a deep and solid unity.

Illustration for the article “Buddhism in Europe, Unity in Diversity: A Challenge, a Model and Hope for Peace in Europe” (EBU Magazine #9)

Nantes

Human beings are capable of the best and of the worst! We witness this on a daily basis, and I would like to give just one edifying example, which also allows me to express my gratitude that this conference could be held in our city.

As a matter of fact, Nantes was the last bastion of resistance in France against the spirit of conciliation and tolerance so desired by King Henry IV of France. The ongoing religious war between Catholics and Protestants in the 16th century had caused the death of tens of thousands of people.

Faced with the stubbornness and continuation of the murderous violence in our city, the King came in person to sign the “Edict of Nantes” (1598). The aim of this Edict was to put an end to this disastrous war by granting Protestants the freedom to worship! Unfortunately, I have to mention that this Edict was revoked barely a century later in 1685!

I am convinced that our meeting today on this important theme of unity in diversity, in this port city which also actively participated in the triangular trade, constitutes dynamic repentance. Is not every action that contributes to the acceptance of others, to tolerance and harmony among all beings, a source of Enlightenment and peace for many beings in this visible and invisible world?

In the field of all our relationships, may we, through virtuous deeds, free ourselves from conditionings, sometimes stemming from an immemorial past, which are sources of suffering for others! May we perform acts based on the wisdom of the Teachings and on compassion, factors of Enlightenment and happiness for all!

Let us now examine the diversity of European nations: their models of society, their ways of thinking, their cultures, their beliefs, their religions and their history.

Let us also note how each of them has been shaped in all sorts of ways over the centuries by various and numerous influences, by their exchanges and reciprocal relations, good or bad, and by the links that some of them have maintained with the whole world, thanks to trade and through their colonies, for example.

Each nation has its own characteristics. The effects of their past history are part of their present and future – their good as well as their ill deeds. It is up to us to act to dissolve the negative effects of these deeds!

In the midst of this structural European diversity, let us now examine the diversity of Buddhist traditions.

The Buddha used to preach according to people and circumstances. Thus, according to tradition, there are said to be over 84,000 sutras! The choice of this large number was undoubtedly intended to emphasise the importance of transmitting the Teachings with discernment according to the capacities of each person, just as the Buddha himself did! For the number of sutras of the different Buddhist traditions, even if it is a large one, does not reach this figure.

All traditions, however, whatever their sutras, embrace the fundamental principles of the Buddha’s Teachings: the Teaching on the relative nature of reality, conditioned, submitted to the principles of impermanence, of interdependence, of the dependent origination of causes and effects on the one hand, and on the other hand, on its essential nature and emptiness, as well as on the potential of all beings to free themselves from conditionings and to attain the state of Buddhahood.

Some traditions emphasise specific aspects of the doctrine, others develop around the tutelary figure of a particular great bodhisattva. Their methods of practice may also differ. Some emphasise devotion, others a method of practice more rooted in the reality of links, and others a more solitary practice, withdrawn from the world. This is said in a non-exhaustive way and always bearing in mind that these various schools include in different proportions all the basic Teachings advocated by the Buddha and which contribute to liberation.

Through commercial, intellectual and other exchanges, these traditions, originating in India, spread throughout much of Asia. And thanks to its pragmatic approach to the spiritual path, based on reality, the Buddhist Teaching was then instilled in the cultures of Asian countries with very different characteristics, while naturally impregnating itself with cultural, philosophical or religious elements from these countries.

The Buddha’s Teachings came to Europe from various sources in ancient times. In the 19th century, it aroused the interest of several philosophers who, by the way, often misinterpreted it.

It was in the second half of the 20th century that the important wave of Asian immigration, caused mainly by wars and decolonisation, led to the arrival of Asian masters. At the same time, some Buddhist traditions arrived in Europe thanks to Westerners who had been to various Eastern countries in search of the Buddha’s Teachings.

Such are the main elements of diversity that characterise Buddhism in Europe: a diversity of human beings, a diversity of European nations, a diversity of Buddhist traditions.

How can Buddhism become a model of unity and, even more, a source of inspiration and a factor of peace in Europe?

Sakyamuni Buddha emphasised that one should not worship him, but “rely on oneself and take refuge in the Dharma”. Everyone progresses by learning from the experiences of putting the Teachings into practice.

The Buddha taught a path of self-improvement leading to a state in which the human being is completely transformed and, as a result, becomes capable of transforming the world. This dynamic ‘state’ is an active compassionate relationship with the world, combined with a penetrating vision of the reality of beings.

Thus, in chapter 16 of the Lotus Sutra, the Buddha invites practitioners to focus on a thought that is fundamental to their transformation: “I always know who is following the Path and who is not. I expound the Dharma to all living beings with different methods, according to the means that can save them, focused on this one thought: how can I bring all beings to enter the supreme path and quickly achieve the Buddha within?”

This fundamental question, which we are invited to ask ourselves, with our hearts set on the happiness and Enlightenment of those around us, is a source of many benefits and an exceptional factor of empathy and unity.

It reveals and nurtures the individual potential for acceptance and kindness in every relationship, whether easy or difficult.

It enables the development of a penetrating vision of the other and, consequently, of oneself. It generates gratitude towards all beings, all of whom participate, in a small or large way, in our earthly existence.

It is the basis of the dynamic and joyful repentance that characterises practitioners of the Buddha’s Teachings. It means that differences and obstacles give way to openness of heart, availability of mind and the promise of discoveries that are essential to our transformation.

Aren’t we and all the human beings we are connected to submitted to conditionings of which we are unaware? Do all these people not deserve our gratitude for spurring on inner practice? Don’t they enable us to seek beyond ourselves clear insight and unconditional love?

We walk the Path knowing that everything that disturbs us or challenges us can become a source of liberation! We walk the Path by making our differences a source of wisdom and compassion. Diversity, the truth of our reality, is the field of our transformation and our Enlightenment.

Buddhist traditions are many and diverse. But is this not in keeping with the teaching on the fundamental diversity of beings? What revelations does the Buddha make about this?

Let’s listen to this excerpt from the parable “Herbs” in chapter 5 of the Lotus Sutra, which answers our question. Not only does this parable highlight the omniscience and omnipresence of the Buddha, but also the universality and plurality of his teaching: “An immense cloud covers the earth and pours everywhere, in a uniform manner, an abundant quantity of rain which waters herbs, plants, small and large trees and vegetation of all kinds. The same rain, poured by this cloud, nourishes each plant which grows, flowers and bears fruit according to its qualities, its characters and its particular nature…

The Buddha appears in the world exactly like this great cloud which covers the whole universe. The Dharma he teaches is like the single-flavoured rain. It waters mankind, so that each may reach maturity, the state of Buddhahood. To all, without discrimination, he teaches the supreme Dharma, the Buddha’s Dharma that leads to Enlightenment.”

In this chapter, the Buddha explains that until now, aware of the inclinations of human beings, he has taught the Dharma with various skilful means according to people’s capacities. Then he makes this revelation: there is only one path, the single Buddhist Vehicle. All practitioners are bodhisattvas, beings who progress towards supreme Enlightenment.

As each plant receives the amount of water it needs, a water unique in appearance and flavour, the Buddha says he teaches a Dharma of unique flavour to all equally. The plants symbolise the diversity of practitioners and their varying capacities to hear the Teachings. These heavenly descriptions of all forms of plants growing in harmony and interdependence, absorbing water according to their needs, is a true celebration of diversity and unity!

Illustration for the article “Buddhism in Europe, Unity in Diversity: A Challenge, a Model and Hope for Peace in Europe” (EBU Magazine #9)

Whatever their tradition, practitioners make every effort to put into practice the Teachings they are capable of hearing at any given moment. These Teachings are all of the single Buddha-vehicle. Everyone has encountered the Dharma through their karmic connection with the Buddha and a particular tradition. The diversity of Buddhist schools and traditions is a precious opportunity for human beings, so diverse in their nature and aspirations, to encounter the unique flavour of the Dharma through the tradition that inspires them.

I would like to conclude by mentioning my personal experience within the EBU. It illustrates how much progress can be made by benevolently sharing with others who are different in nature, and in this case, by sharing with different traditions.

Each year’s gathering at the EBU General Meeting has allowed me, through the spontaneous exchanges and careful listening to the lectures, to examine the goals of my practice, to question the quality of my aspiration, my ability to hear the Teachings and how I cared about others.

These were profound and joyful moments of sincere and fruitful spiritual friendship. By its example of openness and tolerance, the EBU is potentially a source of inspiration and I can’t but hope that it will be a model of harmony and peace for Europe.


About the author

Claudine Carayol-Shinoda was born in 1949 in Saint-Malo, France. Qualified in French literature, she went to Japan at the age of 24, where she studied Japanese “sumié” painting under the guidance of Hattori-Shofu, a Zen monk, for five years, while teaching French literature at Nagoya University. She met Reiyukai, Spiritual Friendship Buddhism, in Japan and came back to France with her husband with the common goal of spreading the Reiyukai teachings in France. Translator of the Lotus Sutra, other sutras and various Buddhist texts, she dedicates her life to practising and promoting the Reiyukai teachings while continuing to paint. Vice-president of the EBU for six years, she was its president from 2005 until 2008. She is president of Reiyukai, Spiritual Friendship Buddhism, in France.

This article first appeared in EBU Magazine #9 – EBU Conference 2022 – Buddhism in Europe: Unity in Diversity (Autumn 2022). Download the full issue as PDF or browse all issues.

Прокрутка до верху