Closer Together: Karma

By Shenpen Rinpoche – Talk at the EBU conference “Buddhism in Europe: Unity in Diversity”, Nantes, April 2022

Silhouettes of a group of people on a hilltop under a bright sky with a contrail

Today I would like to lead the discussions towards the idea of the reality of our existence and how we perceive this, and especially to realise that we all share a common reality and the very similar way in which we create this reality. At the moment in the world there are a great many attempts to divide and separate people, as the saying goes divide to better control and reign, and it is important to avoid this, and we, and especially those who practice the Dharma should concentrate the centre of their attention on understanding the law of causality, the law of Karma, which constructs what we consider as our reality is at the base of our existence. A good understanding of this mechanism would allow us to come closer together, not to divide ourselves and to practice Bodhicitta with more force, implication, and more conviction.

The law of causality, commonly known as the law of Karma is one of the most fundamental laws, and at the same time one of the most complex mechanisms to understand. Some texts say that only fully enlightened Buddhas can really grasp the meaning of this in all its complexity with the different parameters which are linked together to construct what we call our reality.

In order to be brief about a subject which could take months, we should remember that each time we think, we speak or we act we generate a certain energy, and this energy will be tinged by our intentions. It is the intention we put into our words, our thoughts and our actions which make this energy we create an energy which will be positive, negative or neutral. So we create almost permanently positive, negative or neutral causes. There are only a few moments of deep sleep when we do not think but all the rest of the time we are in the process of continually generating energies. These energies, like a chemical preparation where we add little elements here and there, accumulate and come together like small pieces of a puzzle and after a time this preparation will react and will produce a result. This result becomes one of our perceptions. We have six senses, five physical senses and one mental sense and the result of this causality, the phenomena appear to us through one of these six senses. This means that when some Karmas reach maturity they produce results and we perceive these results. The result can be a situation, a meeting, an accident, something we can see or hear. And as it is a phenomenon and a process which is being put into place constantly it is what makes our reality. When we see, if it will be only the wall in front of us, it is a phenomenon. I perceive this phenomenon because I have created the cause. If I had not created the causes of perceiving this wall, I would not perceive it. If I had not created the causes of seeing the sun rise I would not see it rising. There is nothing we perceive for which we have not created the causes.

These are ideas which it is very important to understand, and which avoid a lot of extra negativity which we could project onto what we might consider as being the exterior. We have a tendency to think that all our pain and all our problems and difficulties are the result of the exterior, of people, situations, governments which exist on their own, intrinsically. Whereas the advanced study of the Dharma shows us that all these phenomena do not exist independently. Everything we perceive exists and depends completely on the causes we have created. I have created the causes of what is happening to me in my life, in my reality, and this is true for each individual.

I cannot purify other people’s negative Karmas, I cannot directly modify other people’s Karmas. Possibly I can teach, I can show by example, write a poem, draw a drawing, something that will make the other person react so that possibly he or she will change their own Karma, will modify the causality which has been created and which is continually being created. The Karma is not something that is engraved in marble forever. Karma is something very fluid which is continually moving. As we think continually we add little pieces of energy continually. By doing this every day we can modify the Karma which has been previously created. There are even specific practices which permit the purifying of negative Karmas which have been accumulated in past years or even in past lives. For example I think of the practice of Vajrasattva, the 100 syllables mantra, but also practices like the liberation of animals where we save animals and release them to freedom. These are practices which have a very important impact on the causes which have been previously accumulated.

Each individual works in the same way, that is to say, in the world where we are, beings we perceive or beings we do not perceive exist and function in the same way we do. My neighbour has a life, has a reality based on the same principle as mine. This reflection can lead us, should lead us, not to divide ourselves, not to have the impression that there are beings so different from us. There are no beings so different from us. Even in other kingdoms, if we think for example of the kingdom of animals, the lives of the animals are based on the same mechanism as ours. There are also created Karmic causes there, probably less consciously than us. But animals have Karmic causes and they have created causes in previous existences which have led them to be born again as animals. It is the same thing for the kingdom of spirits, the kingdom of the divine beings like Titans semi gods. All beings exist and perceive with the same mechanism. If we understand this mechanism well it brings us to understand that we have all had links in the past. We exist since time immemorial, since such ancient times when all the beings were the members of the same family. They were loved, fed and helped each other many many times. The family circle we may have today is the result of the nearest connections, only several lives. The people towards whom we are more indifferent we have certainly met but a very long time ago. All these beings have a similar quest. There is a quest for happiness but we have a tendency to mix up pleasure with happiness and especially immediate pleasure with long term happiness. Therefore we make many mistakes as when looking for immediate pleasure we generate a lot of attachments, we can generate jealousy, mental states and thoughts which are not always virtuous and can generate more negativity and weigh down a little more the negative Karma which we may have.

So if we have had the good luck to meet the Dharma, to receive teachings, to meditate, to practice, we understand better this mechanism of causality, we understand better the inherent absence of existence of the phenomena. This inherent absence of existence is coupled with the impermanence of the phenomena which never stay indefinitely in the same state. This is also a phenomenon based on the causality because a phenomenon appears as it appears to us based on this causality. Certain causes have been accumulated to perceive this phenomenon in the way which we perceive it. These causes, this energy exhaust themselves over time. After some time the causes of the phenomenon disappear and the phenomenon disappears. Thus the way we perceive things will modify itself with time, with education, with teaching, with practice, everything that builds our life. So the phenomena are impermanent, there is no phenomenon which exists on its own independently of the person who perceives it and which remains forever in the same state.

So in everyday life we can see a great deal of diversity of phenomena, a great diversity of people, great diversity of different cultural contributions and this is the result of the causality of all beings. Accepting this diversity, accepting that this diversity sometimes causes us to ask ourselves questions is also admitting that all beings function in a way that is similar to ours but at the same time different, because they have had different lives, different education, because they come from a different culture.

This is true generally and it should be even more true within Buddhism.

Within the Dharma we have numerous families, numerous branches which have developed over time and geographically and which sometimes take certain aspects of the Dharma and focus more on some of these aspects compared with others and this is certainly done to meet the multitude of expectations of sensitive beings. We have different expectations, we have different quests in our lives, different spiritual desires and the Dharma, through its different aspects, is able to bring answers to these.

Illustration for the article “Closer Together: Karma” (EBU Magazine #9)

Of course there are other religions, other spiritual and philosophical movements which are present to meet other expectations, other desires and they can be respected as long as they respect other sensitive beings, and this is what should define a religion, a spirituality. So we are the result of a great multitude of beings and the way we perceive them depends on the causes we have created. A good healthy understanding of the law of causality, of Karma, enables us to be much more open, much more attentive, much more generous as well, because, as I have said, it is important to understand that this law of causality is continual and constant until we reach enlightenment. That is to say that at one moment it is important to ask ourselves what we want in life, and if we are really looking for ultimate happiness which is not impermanent then we must also adapt our lives, our practices and our way of thinking so as to reach this goal. While doing this, if I search for happiness, I must first stop creating causes of suffering, I must stop creating causes which in the future will manifest themselves as unpleasant situations. I must increase the accumulation of positive Karma of positive causes, and this is done by practice of the six perfections for example, the practice of generosity, of patience, joyful effort etc. up to the development of wisdom. It is through this practice that I will be able to progress. And through this development, this understanding of causality I will generate fewer and fewer attachments concerning this reality. Why is this, simply because as I realize that this reality is illusory why should I need to attach myself to it, why should I need to project continually the phenomena I seize towards the exterior, whilst I understand better and better that everything I perceive in this reality is in fact a whole set of phenomena which are perceived inside my own spirit.

The better I understand the law of causality, the better I understand that everything I perceive results from causes that I accumulated previously, the less I attach myself to them, the less I seize them the less I project negativity as coming from the exterior, in fact there is none. So if, at certain times, there are situations which are not pleasant, they are the result of causes which I have previously accumulated and I must experience them or I must purify them, but in both cases reacting to an unpleasant situation in a negative manner cannot bring more happiness.

Whatever the situation I am living through, whatever the surroundings, pleasant or unpleasant, it is my today’s mental state that will decide what I will experience tomorrow. Hence the importance of “Here and Now”, that is to say being conscious of the present moment because when we speak about this law of causality the present moment is the most important one. It is the moment I can change, it is the moment on which I can have influence, it is the moment which I can make beneficial, even if I had started off with a mental state which was a little disturbed I can change this at any moment, that is my choice. I don’t know the previously accumulated causes. Of course I can influence them to a certain extent by purifying practice, but I cannot change everything.

Notably, I cannot change what I perceive today as my reality my surroundings as it has already been manifested; it is already in the field of my perception and I cannot change this and it would be difficult to modify. However, on the other hand what I can change and what is in my hands is my state of mind. I can let it slide, let it be taken over by negativity or I can become aware of this causality, of the importance of my state of mind on the things I create, how I create and perceive things, my surroundings, the others. And that is something I can change, something I can improve and the improvement of this state of mind, here and now, today, will have an impact on the moments which will follow, the months, the years, and even in some cases lives that will follow.

So that was the subject I wanted to share with you during the time I was given, causality, and the importance of understanding this law of causality in order to better live the present and to create causes for the future which will be more in step with a search for happiness, and a search for help to bring to others.

Illustration for the article “Closer Together: Karma” (EBU Magazine #9)

About the author

Lama Shenpen Rinpoche was born in 1969 in France. He entered Nalanda Monastery at the age of 16 and joined Sera Je Monastic University in 1990, where he spent about ten years, studying but also taking care of the dispensary. Early in his monastic life Rinpoche was recognised as the tulku of Lama Gendun Rabgye, a Geshe from Kharnang Monastery, Kham, Tibet. Rinpoche spent a few years in Greece, Spain and Slovenia and continues to travel, teaching and transmitting the Dharma as a lay Lama. Now the father of five, Rinpoche has a unique and very practical way of teaching, based on daily life.

This article first appeared in EBU Magazine #9 – EBU Conference 2022 – Buddhism in Europe: Unity in Diversity (Autumn 2022). Download the full issue as PDF or browse all issues.

Nach oben scrollen